Boeing 747-400 vs DC-10: Jumbo Quad or Trijet?

Boeing 747-400 vs DC-10 compared: four engines against three, a 1989 glass cockpit against 1970s analog gauges, and two very different safety stories.

Updated:

Add AeroCorner as a preferred source on Google
Boeing 747-400 and McDonnell Douglas DC-10-40 compared side by side
Boeing 747-400 and McDonnell Douglas DC-10-40 compared side by side – © Martin Oertle / composite by AeroCorner

The Boeing 747-400 is the bigger, longer-legged and far newer aircraft: a four-engine jumbo with a two-pilot glass cockpit. The DC-10 is a smaller three-engine trijet that first flew in 1970, 18 years before the 747-400.

The DC-10 was a smaller wide-body for thinner routes. Its record was marred by two accidents, American 191 in 1979 and United 232 in 1989.

Boeing 747-400
Jumbo Passenger Jets
Boeing 747-400
McDonnell Douglas DC-10-40
Jumbo Passenger Jets
McDonnell Douglas DC-10-40

General

Units
Boeing 747-400
Manufacturer
Boeing
ICAO code
B744
Produced
1989–2009
Price
$266.5 million (2007)
Engine
4 × Pratt & Whitney PW4000 / General Electric CF6-80C2 / Rolls-Royce RB211-524
Engine type
Turbofan
Thrust
4 × 63,300 lbf · 282 kN +59% (total)
Avionics
Honeywell flight management computer, Rockwell Collins central maintenance computer
Wing tips
Canted winglets
Seats
416 economy · 524 business · 416 first
Crew
2
McDonnell Douglas DC-10-40
Manufacturer
McDonnell Douglas
ICAO code
DC10
Produced
1973–1983
Price
$20 million (1972)
Engine
3 × Pratt & Whitney JT9D-59A
Engine type
Jet
Thrust
3 × 53,000 lbf · 236 kN -37% (total)
Avionics
—
Wing tips
No winglets
Seats
399
Crew
—

Dimensions

Boeing 747-400
Cabin width
20 ft 1 in 6.13 m 20 ft 1 in 6.13 m +8%
Cabin height
8 ft 4 in 2.54 m 8 ft 4 in 2.54 m +5%
Cabin length
187 ft 0 in 57.00 m 187 ft 0 in 57.00 m +55%
Exterior length
231 ft 10 in 70.66 m 231 ft 10 in 70.66 m +27%
Tail height
63 ft 8 in 19.41 m 63 ft 8 in 19.41 m +11%
Fuselage diameter
21 ft 4 in 6.49 m 21 ft 4 in 6.49 m +8%
Wing span
211 ft 5 in 64.44 m 211 ft 5 in 64.44 m +28%
Baggage volume
525 ft 3 in 160.10 m 525 ft 3 in 160.10 m +22%
McDonnell Douglas DC-10-40
Cabin width
18 ft 8 in 5.70 m 18 ft 8 in 5.70 m -7%
Cabin height
7 ft 11 in 2.41 m 7 ft 11 in 2.41 m -5%
Cabin length
120 ft 5 in 36.70 m 120 ft 5 in 36.70 m -36%
Exterior length
182 ft 3 in 55.54 m 182 ft 3 in 55.54 m -21%
Tail height
57 ft 7 in 17.55 m 57 ft 7 in 17.55 m -10%
Fuselage diameter
19 ft 8 in 6.00 m 19 ft 8 in 6.00 m -8%
Wing span
165 ft 4 in 50.39 m 165 ft 4 in 50.39 m -22%
Baggage volume
428 ft 10 in 130.70 m 428 ft 10 in 130.70 m -18%

Weights

Boeing 747-400
Empty weight
404,600 lb 183,523 kg 404,600 lb 183,523 kg
Max payload
157,500 lb 71,500 kg 157,500 lb 71,500 kg +61%
Fuel capacity
57,285 gal 216,847 L 57,285 gal 216,847 L +56%
Max takeoff weight
875,000 lb 397,000 kg 875,000 lb 397,000 kg +58%
Max landing weight
652,000 lb 295,500 kg 652,000 lb 295,500 kg +62%
McDonnell Douglas DC-10-40
Empty weight
— — —
Max payload
98,000 lb 44,400 kg 98,000 lb 44,400 kg -38%
Fuel capacity
36,652 gal 138,743 L 36,652 gal 138,743 L -36%
Max takeoff weight
555,000 lb 251,500 kg 555,000 lb 251,500 kg -37%
Max landing weight
403,000 lb 183,000 kg 403,000 lb 183,000 kg -38%

Performance

Boeing 747-400
Max cruise speed
528 kt · 608 mph 978 km/h 528 kt 608 mph 978 km/h 0%
Max speed
528 kt · 608 mph 978 km/h 528 kt 608 mph 978 km/h
Cruise speed
490 kt · 564 mph 907 km/h 490 kt 564 mph 907 km/h
Approach speed
157 kt · 181 mph 291 km/h 157 kt 181 mph 291 km/h +5%
Rate of climb
1,500 ft/min 8 m/s 1,500 ft/min 8 m/s -25%
Range
7,285 nm · 8,380 mi 13,490 km 7,285 nm 8,380 mi 13,490 km +43%
Service ceiling
45,000 ft 13,700 m 45,000 ft 13,700 m +7%
Takeoff distance
9,700 ft 2,960 m 9,700 ft 2,960 m +2%
Landing distance
7,150 ft 2,180 m 7,150 ft 2,180 m +21%
McDonnell Douglas DC-10-40
Max cruise speed
530 kt · 610 mph 982 km/h 530 kt 610 mph 982 km/h +0%
Max speed
— — —
Cruise speed
— — —
Approach speed
149 kt · 171 mph 276 km/h 149 kt 171 mph 276 km/h -5%
Rate of climb
2,000 ft/min 10 m/s 2,000 ft/min 10 m/s +33%
Range
5,100 nm · 5,870 mi 9,450 km 5,100 nm 5,870 mi 9,450 km -30%
Service ceiling
42,000 ft 12,800 m 42,000 ft 12,800 m -7%
Takeoff distance
9,500 ft 2,900 m 9,500 ft 2,900 m -2%
Landing distance
5,900 ft 1,800 m 5,900 ft 1,800 m -17%

McDonnell Douglas DC-10-40 comparisons

No other comparisons yet.

Table of Contents

MeasureBoeing 747-400DC-10
First flightApril 29, 1988August 29, 1970 (the DC-10 family)
Entered serviceFebruary 9, 1989, with Northwest AirlinesAugust 5, 1971, with American Airlines (the DC-10 family)
Engine layoutFour, all on wing pylonsThree: two on the wings, one in the tail
Number built694, delivered 1989 to 2009386 airliners across all series, 42 of them DC-10-40s
Cockpit generationTwo-crew glass cockpitAnalog gauges (see the photo below)
Passenger service todayRetired by Air India in 2022 and Asiana in 2024, still flown by some carriersLast scheduled flight: Biman Bangladesh Airlines, February 20, 2014
Sizes, weights, range and speeds sit in the spec comparison above, which uses the DC-10-40. Sources: Wikipedia, Boeing 747-400 and McDonnell Douglas DC-10 articles.

How the 747-400 and DC-10 came about

The Boeing 747-400 is the final passenger version of Boeing’s jumbo jet. It first flew on April 29, 1988, and entered service on February 9, 1989, with Northwest Airlines, the launch customer.

The DC-10 came from McDonnell Douglas. It first flew on August 29, 1970, and began service on August 5, 1971, with American Airlines. The spec comparison above shows the McDonnell Douglas DC-10-40, one of the 42 long-range -40s.

The comparison is therefore not a fair fight between contemporaries. The DC-10 is a 1970s design and the 747-400 is a 1980s update of an older one.

Myth check: the DC-10 did not have an excellent safety record

An earlier version of this page claimed the DC-10 had one of the lowest hull loss rates of any wide-body. The record says otherwise. American Airlines Flight 191 crashed at Chicago O’Hare on May 25, 1979, killing all 271 people aboard and two on the ground. The FAA withdrew the type certificate on June 6, 1979, and lifted the ban on July 13, 1979. As of February 2025, one count lists 55 accidents and incidents, 32 hull-loss accidents and 1,261 occupant fatalities.

Passenger, freighter and Combi: the 747-400 family

The 747-400 was sold in several forms. Boeing built 442 standard passenger jets, 19 shorter-range 400Ds and 6 extended-range 400ERs.

The freighter side was just as large: 126 400Fs and 40 400ERFs. Another 61 were Combis, which carry passengers and cargo on the same main deck.

That mix is why the type lasted. When airlines retired passenger 747-400s, the freighters kept the model in the air.

Engines and layout

The 747-400 has four engines on wing pylons. Buyers chose Pratt & Whitney PW4000, General Electric CF6-80C2 or Rolls-Royce RB211-524G/H power.

The DC-10 has three engines. Two hang under the wings, and the third sits in a banjo-shaped structure on top of the rear fuselage at the base of the tail fin.

The older version of this page said the 747 has three engines and a “tricycle” layout. That was wrong: the 747 is a quad, and the tail-mounted third engine is a DC-10 trait.

How to tell a 747-400 from a DC-10

Count the engines first. A 747-400 has four, two under each wing. A DC-10 has three, with the third mounted at the base of the tail fin.

Size is the second clue. The spec comparison above lists the dimensions, and the 747-400 is longer and wider across the wings than the DC-10-40.

The 747-400 also has winglets about 6 feet (1.8 m) tall on its extended wingtips. The DC-10-40 has no winglets, which the spec panel confirms.

Finally, check the age. A DC-10 on the ramp today is almost certainly in a museum, a photo archive or a storage yard, since scheduled passenger flying ended in 2014.

Where the 747-400 wins

A modern two-pilot flight deck

The 747-400 has a two-crew glass cockpit. Boeing eliminated the flight engineer position, which cut the workload and the crew count.

Production run and variety

Boeing delivered 694 747-400s between 1989 and 2009. That was 442 passenger jets, 126 freighters and 61 Combis, plus the 400D, 400ER and 400ERF.

The final one was a 747-400ERF freighter delivered to Kalitta Air on December 22, 2009. The last passenger 747-400 had been delivered in April 2005.

Where the DC-10 wins

Three series for different jobs

The DC-10 family came in three airliner series. McDonnell Douglas built 122 DC-10-10s, 163 DC-10-30s and 42 DC-10-40s.

The -10 was the original model with three GE CF6-6D engines and a range of 3,500 nautical miles. The -30 and -40 added a center main landing gear and flew longer routes. The McDonnell Douglas DC-10-40 used Pratt & Whitney JT9D engines.

The DC-10 also had a military life. McDonnell Douglas built 60 KC-10 tankers alongside the 386 airliners, so the family totals 446 aircraft.

The last airliner left the line in 1989, delivered to Nigeria Airways in July of that year. The 747-400 outlasted that date by 20 years.

Two numbers capture the DC-10-10, the original model. It had a maximum takeoff weight of 430,000 lb (195,045 kg) and a typical two-class layout of 270 seats, 222 economy and 48 business.

A smaller wide-body for thinner routes

A trijet with a typical two-class layout of about 270 seats in the -10 suited routes where a full 747 was too much aircraft. That is the DC-10’s real selling point against the jumbo.

Not every DC-10 accident was fatal for all aboard

United Airlines Flight 232 crash-landed at Sioux City, Iowa, on July 19, 1989. Of the people aboard, 184 survived and 112 died.

The two accidents that shaped the DC-10’s reputation

American Airlines Flight 191 is the DC-10’s worst accident. It crashed at Chicago O’Hare on May 25, 1979, killing all 271 people aboard and two on the ground.

The FAA withdrew the type certificate on June 6, 1979. It lifted the ban on July 13, 1979, after about five weeks.

Ten years later, United Airlines Flight 232 came down at Sioux City, Iowa, on July 19, 1989. The crash killed 112 people and 184 survived, and the crew training lessons from it are covered in our story of United 232.

Across the whole DC-10 history, Wikipedia counts 55 accidents and incidents, 32 hull-loss accidents and 1,261 occupant fatalities as of February 2025. Those totals cover every operator and every year of service.

The 747-400 has its own accident history, but it is not summarized here, because we did not verify a comparable count. Treat the DC-10 figures as a reminder of the era, not a head-to-head safety ranking.

Which is better?

The 747-400 is the better aircraft in size, range and cockpit technology, and it stayed in production for two decades longer. It is the obvious choice when you want maximum capacity on a long route.

The DC-10 was a good fit for medium-haul wide-body routes in its day. Airlines retired it from scheduled passenger service in 2014, and the 747-400 has outlived it.

For the jumbo’s wider story, see how many 747s are still flying.

FAQ

Yes. The 747-400 is a four-engine jumbo with a typical three-class layout of 416 seats, while the DC-10 is a three-engine wide-body that is smaller in every dimension listed in the spec comparison above.
Three. Two hang under the wings and the third sits in a banjo-shaped structure on top of the rear fuselage, at the base of the tail fin.
The 747 did. The 747-400 first flew on April 29, 1988, but the original 747 was already in service well before the DC-10, which first flew on August 29, 1970 and entered service on August 5, 1971 with American Airlines.
The -10 was the original model with GE CF6-6D engines and a range of 3,500 nautical miles. The -40 used Pratt & Whitney JT9D engines for longer routes, and only 42 were built, against 122 of the -10.
Not on scheduled passenger routes. Biman Bangladesh Airlines flew the last scheduled passenger service on February 20, 2014, from Dhaka to Birmingham, and local charters continued until February 24, 2014.
Yes, mainly as a freighter. Passenger 747-400s have been retired by many airlines, and Air India and Asiana flew their last ones in 2022 and 2024.

About the Author

Tim de Vries

Tim is the owner and lead editor of AeroCorner since 2019, overseeing aviation content covering aircraft, airlines, airports, and the broader aviation industry. Through years of researching, writing, editing, and publishing aviation-focused content, he has developed extensive practical knowledge of commercial aviation and air travel. Based in Asia and a frequent traveler himself, Tim also brings firsthand passenger experience to AeroCorner’s coverage. Outside of publishing, he has also explored aviation firsthand through hands-on flight training in New Zealand.