F4U Corsair vs F6F Hellcat: Which Navy Fighter Was Better?

F4U Corsair vs F6F Hellcat compared: speed, carrier landings, guns and kill ratios, and why the Navy picked the Hellcat for its decks.

Updated:

Add AeroCorner as a preferred source on Google
Vought F4U Corsair and Grumman F6F Hellcat compared side by side
Vought F4U Corsair and Grumman F6F Hellcat compared side by side – © Eric Denison / airwolfhound / composite by AeroCorner

The Hellcat was the better carrier fighter and the Corsair was the faster, better ground-attack aircraft. The Navy picked the Hellcat for its decks in 1943 because pilots could land it.

The Hellcat claimed more victories, 5,163 to 2,140, and a 19:1 kill-to-loss ratio against the Corsair's 11:1. The Corsair outran it and stayed in production until 1953.

Vought F4U Corsair
Military Propellor Planes
Vought F4U Corsair
ICAO: F4U Military: F4U-4 Visit aircraft page
Grumman F6F Hellcat
Military Propellor Planes
Grumman F6F Hellcat

General

Units
Vought F4U Corsair
Manufacturer
Vought
ICAO code
F4U
Military code
F4U-4
Produced
1942–1953
Price
—
Engine
1 × Pratt & Whitney R-2800-18W Double Wasp
Engine type
Piston
Power
2,100 hp · 1,566 kW +5% (total)
Avionics
—
Wing tips
No winglets
Seats
1
Crew
1
Grumman F6F Hellcat
Manufacturer
Grumman
ICAO code
F6F
Military code
—
Produced
1942–1945
Price
$35,000 (1945)
Engine
1 × Pratt & Whitney R-2800 Double Wasp
Engine type
Piston
Power
2,000 hp · 1,491 kW -5% (total)
Avionics
AN/APS-4 Radar
Wing tips
No winglets
Seats
1
Crew
—

Dimensions

Vought F4U Corsair
Exterior length
33 ft 8 in 10.26 m 33 ft 8 in 10.26 m +0%
Tail height
14 ft 9 in 4.50 m 14 ft 9 in 4.50 m +13%
Fuselage diameter
4 ft 3 in 1.30 m 4 ft 3 in 1.30 m -13%
Wing span
41 ft 0 in 12.50 m 41 ft 0 in 12.50 m -4%
Grumman F6F Hellcat
Exterior length
33 ft 7 in 10.24 m 33 ft 7 in 10.24 m 0%
Tail height
13 ft 1 in 3.99 m 13 ft 1 in 3.99 m -11%
Fuselage diameter
4 ft 11 in 1.50 m 4 ft 11 in 1.50 m +15%
Wing span
42 ft 10 in 13.06 m 42 ft 10 in 13.06 m +4%

Weights

Vought F4U Corsair
Empty weight
9,205 lb 4,175 kg 9,205 lb 4,175 kg 0%
Max payload
4,000 lb 1,800 kg 4,000 lb 1,800 kg +1%
Fuel capacity
534 gal 2,021 L 534 gal 2,021 L +114%
Max takeoff weight
14,700 lb 6,650 kg 14,700 lb 6,650 kg -5%
Grumman F6F Hellcat
Empty weight
9,238 lb 4,190 kg 9,238 lb 4,190 kg +0%
Max payload
3,950 lb 1,800 kg 3,950 lb 1,800 kg -1%
Fuel capacity
250 gal 946 L 250 gal 946 L -53%
Max takeoff weight
15,400 lb 7,000 kg 15,400 lb 7,000 kg +5%

Performance

Vought F4U Corsair
Max cruise speed
388 kt · 447 mph 719 km/h 388 kt 447 mph 719 km/h +14%
Max speed
388 kt · 447 mph 719 km/h 388 kt 447 mph 719 km/h +14%
Cruise speed
187 kt · 215 mph 346 km/h 187 kt 215 mph 346 km/h
Approach speed
— — —
Rate of climb
4,360 ft/min 22 m/s 4,360 ft/min 22 m/s +68%
Range
873 nm · 1,000 mi 1,620 km 873 nm 1,000 mi 1,620 km +6%
Service ceiling
41,500 ft 12,600 m 41,500 ft 12,600 m +11%
Takeoff distance
— — —
Grumman F6F Hellcat
Max cruise speed
340 kt · 391 mph 630 km/h 340 kt 391 mph 630 km/h -12%
Max speed
340 kt · 391 mph 630 km/h 340 kt 391 mph 630 km/h -12%
Cruise speed
— — —
Approach speed
75 kt · 86 mph 139 km/h 75 kt 86 mph 139 km/h
Rate of climb
2,600 ft/min 13 m/s 2,600 ft/min 13 m/s -40%
Range
821 nm · 940 mi 1,520 km 821 nm 940 mi 1,520 km -6%
Service ceiling
37,300 ft 11,400 m 37,300 ft 11,400 m -10%
Takeoff distance
800 ft 240 m 800 ft 240 m

Table of Contents

F4U Corsair vs F6F Hellcat at a glance

The F4U Corsair and the F6F Hellcat flew the same war, from the same carriers and island airfields, with the same engine family. The numbers they left behind point in different directions.

The Hellcat claimed more victories and a higher kill-to-loss ratio. The Corsair was the faster, harder-hitting ground attacker and ended up with the longer career.

MeasureF4U CorsairF6F Hellcat
Combat debutMarine squadrons, Guadalcanal, February 1943Navy carrier raid on Marcus Island, August 1943
Built12,571 across 16 models12,275
Standard gunsSix .50 in machine gunsSix .50 in machine guns
Air combat victories claimed (U.S. Navy and Marines)2,1405,163
Losses to enemy aircraft189270
Claimed kill-to-loss ratioOver 11:119:1
Combat sorties64,051 (15% from carrier decks)66,530
Cleared for U.S. Navy carriersApril 1944, after a longer landing-gear strutIn service on carriers from its 1943 debut
Claimed figures from U.S. wartime compilations; Hellcat totals do not include Royal Navy use. Sources: Wikipedia F4U and F6F articles, 2026.

Where the Corsair wins: speed and staying power

When the Navy wrote the Corsair’s requirement in 1938, it asked for the maximum obtainable speed. On 1 October 1940 the prototype became the first single-engine U.S. fighter to fly faster than 400 mph (640 km/h).

The spec panel shows the result: 447 mph (719 km/h) for the Corsair against 391 mph (630 km/h) for the Hellcat. The Corsair also stayed in production from 1942 to 1953, the longest run of any U.S. piston-engined fighter.

That bent wing was an engineering workaround. A long landing gear was needed to keep the huge propeller off the ground, and the inverted gull wing let the struts stay short.

The Corsair was also the better bomb truck. U.S. figures credit Corsairs with 70% of the bombs dropped by American fighters in World War II. Some Japanese pilots regarded it as the most formidable American fighter.

Where the Hellcat wins: the carrier deck

A fighter has to land on a ship before it can fight from one. The Navy greatly preferred the Hellcat’s docile handling, even though the Corsair was faster.

Grumman built the Hellcat to take damage and bring the pilot home. It carried 212 pounds (96 kg) of cockpit armor, armor around the oil tank and oil cooler, and a self-sealing fuel tank.

It was also designed to be easy to build and maintain. Those traits are why it became the Navy’s dominant fighter in the second half of the Pacific War, and why David McCampbell called it rugged and easy to maintain. McCampbell, the Navy’s all-time leading ace, scored all 34 of his victories in a Hellcat.

Why the Corsair struggled at sea

Early Corsair pilots called it the “hog,” the “hosenose” and the “bent-wing Widow Maker.” The long nose hid the deck on approach, and the engine’s torque punished a pilot who had to go around.

The landing gear also bounced. Carrier trials in 1942 judged the Corsair an excellent carrier type, but newly trained pilots found landings hazardous.

The Navy handed the fighter to the Marines, who flew from land. The Royal Navy’s Fleet Air Arm, which received 2,012 Corsairs, put the type on carriers from mid 1943 and found its landing manners dangerous but still the best option it had.

The U.S. Navy accepted the Corsair for shipboard use in April 1944, after a longer landing-gear strut cured the bounce. Marine squadrons first operated from USS Essex in December 1944, mainly to counter kamikazes.

Do the kill ratios settle it?

On paper, the Hellcat’s 19:1 beats the Corsair’s 11:1. The Corsair’s own history cautions against reading it that way.

Only 15% of Corsair sorties flew from carriers. As the war moved north, the Corsair’s job shifted to ground attack, so it spent less time facing enemy fighters than the Hellcat did.

Both ratios are claims, not audited results. U.S. pilots also faced increasingly inexperienced Japanese aviators after 1942 and had a growing numerical edge.

Corsair vs Hellcat against the Zero

Both fighters were built to beat Japan’s Mitsubishi A6M Zero. In trials against a captured A6M5, the Hellcat was faster at every altitude, though the Zero turned tighter at low speed.

U.S. pilots were told not to dogfight a Zero but to use power and speed and choose the moment. Claimed ratios against the Zero were 13:1 for the Hellcat and 12:1 for the Corsair, so neither had a clear edge.

For another matchup, see how the Hellcat compares with the Zero and with the P-51 Mustang. Many more are in our guide to American fighters of World War II.

Armament: six machine guns each, and a cannon option

Both fighters usually carried six .50 in M2 Browning machine guns. Four 20 mm cannon were not the Corsair’s standard fit. That layout belonged to the F4U-1C.

Vought built 200 F4U-1Cs in 1944, which swapped the machine guns for four 20 mm cannon and reached combat at Okinawa in 1945. Some Hellcat night fighters carried two 20 mm cannon plus four machine guns.

Which was better, the Corsair or the Hellcat?

For the Navy’s carriers in 1943, the Hellcat was the better fighter because pilots could land it. For speed, ground attack and a long postwar career, including Korea, the Corsair was the better aircraft.

Most of the answer comes down to the job. The spec panel above shows the performance gap, and the table shows the record.

After 1945: Korea, the Blue Angels and the French Navy

The Corsair kept flying. In Korea it served mostly as a close-support aircraft, and the last Corsair was delivered to France in 1953.

The Hellcat faded sooner. Radar-equipped F6F-5N night fighters stayed in U.S. service until 1954, and an F6F-5 was the first aircraft the Navy’s Blue Angels flew in 1946.

Britain also flew both types. The Fleet Air Arm received 1,263 Hellcats under Lend-Lease and 2,012 Corsairs.

FAQ

It depends on the job. The Hellcat was easier to land on a carrier and claimed a higher kill-to-loss ratio, 19:1 against over 11:1. The Corsair was faster and carried more bombs in the ground-attack role.
The Navy’s 1938 requirement for the Corsair asked for the maximum obtainable speed, and its prototype passed 400 mph in October 1940. The Hellcat was designed to survive damage and be easy to build, and carried 212 pounds of cockpit armor. Both used the Pratt & Whitney R-2800 Double Wasp engine family.
The Hellcat. U.S. Navy and Marine Hellcat pilots claimed 5,163 victories, and including Royal Navy use the total was 5,223. Corsair pilots claimed 2,140 air combat victories.
The Corsair had poor forward visibility, a tendency to bounce on landing and heavy engine torque, which made it hard for newly trained pilots on carriers. The Marines flew from land bases, so those problems mattered less.
They were about equal. Both usually carried six .50 in machine guns. The Corsair’s four-cannon version, the F4U-1C, was built in small numbers, 200 in 1944.

About the Author

Tim de Vries

Tim is the owner and lead editor of AeroCorner since 2019, overseeing aviation content covering aircraft, airlines, airports, and the broader aviation industry. Through years of researching, writing, editing, and publishing aviation-focused content, he has developed extensive practical knowledge of commercial aviation and air travel. Based in Asia and a frequent traveler himself, Tim also brings firsthand passenger experience to AeroCorner’s coverage. Outside of publishing, he has also explored aviation firsthand through hands-on flight training in New Zealand.