P-40 Warhawk vs Spitfire: Which WWII Fighter Was Better?

P-40 vs Spitfire: the Spitfire wins as a fighter, but the Warhawk's six guns and dive speed earned it a record of its own. See how they compare.

Updated:

Add AeroCorner as a preferred source on Google
Curtiss P-40 Warhawk and Supermarine Spitfire compared side by side
Curtiss P-40 Warhawk and Supermarine Spitfire compared side by side – © Bidgee / Alan Wilson / composite by AeroCorner

The Spitfire was the better fighter, especially above 15,000 feet. Its two-stage Merlin kept power at altitude, while the P-40's single-stage Allison faded.

The P-40 had its own strengths: six .50 caliber guns on the E model, one of the best dive speeds of the early war, and a combat record from the desert to China to the Pacific.

Curtiss P-40 Warhawk
Military Propellor Planes
Curtiss P-40 Warhawk
ICAO: P40 Military: P-40E Visit aircraft page
Supermarine Spitfire
Military Propellor Planes
Supermarine Spitfire

General

Units
Curtiss P-40 Warhawk
Manufacturer
Curtiss
ICAO code
P40
Military code
P-40E
Produced
1939–1944
Price
$45,000 (1944)
Engine
1 × Allison V-1710-39
Engine type
Piston
Power
1,150 hp · 858 kW -22% (total)
Wing tips
No winglets
Seats
1
Crew
1
Supermarine Spitfire
Manufacturer
Supermarine
ICAO code
SPIT
Military code
—
Produced
1938–1948
Price
$16,000 (1939)
Engine
1 × Rolls-Royce Merlin 45 V-12
Engine type
Piston
Power
1,470 hp · 1,096 kW +28% (total)
Wing tips
No winglets
Seats
1
Crew
1

Dimensions

Curtiss P-40 Warhawk
Exterior length
31 ft 8 in 9.66 m 31 ft 8 in 9.66 m +6%
Tail height
12 ft 4 in 3.77 m 12 ft 4 in 3.77 m +8%
Fuselage diameter
3 ft 3 in 1.00 m 3 ft 3 in 1.00 m +11%
Wing span
37 ft 4 in 11.38 m 37 ft 4 in 11.38 m +1%
Supermarine Spitfire
Exterior length
29 ft 11 in 9.12 m 29 ft 11 in 9.12 m -6%
Tail height
11 ft 5 in 3.48 m 11 ft 5 in 3.48 m -8%
Fuselage diameter
2 ft 11 in 0.90 m 2 ft 11 in 0.90 m -10%
Wing span
36 ft 10 in 11.23 m 36 ft 10 in 11.23 m -1%

Weights

Curtiss P-40 Warhawk
Empty weight
6,350 lb 2,880 kg 6,350 lb 2,880 kg +25%
Max payload
700 lb 300 kg 700 lb 300 kg
Fuel capacity
157 gal 594 L 157 gal 594 L +54%
Max takeoff weight
9,200 lb 4,150 kg 9,200 lb 4,150 kg +37%
Max landing weight
— — —
Supermarine Spitfire
Empty weight
5,065 lb 2,297 kg 5,065 lb 2,297 kg -20%
Max payload
— — —
Fuel capacity
102 gal 386 L 102 gal 386 L -35%
Max takeoff weight
6,700 lb 3,050 kg 6,700 lb 3,050 kg -27%
Max landing weight
6,600 lb 3,000 kg 6,600 lb 3,000 kg

Performance

Curtiss P-40 Warhawk
Max cruise speed
314 kt · 361 mph 582 km/h 314 kt 361 mph 582 km/h -2%
Max speed
314 kt · 361 mph 582 km/h 314 kt 361 mph 582 km/h -2%
Cruise speed
268 kt · 308 mph 496 km/h 268 kt 308 mph 496 km/h
Approach speed
83 kt · 96 mph 154 km/h 83 kt 96 mph 154 km/h +22%
Rate of climb
2,100 ft/min 11 m/s 2,100 ft/min 11 m/s -19%
Range
622 nm · 720 mi 1,150 km 622 nm 720 mi 1,150 km -35%
Service ceiling
29,000 ft 8,800 m 29,000 ft 8,800 m -21%
Takeoff distance
— — —
Landing distance
— — —
Supermarine Spitfire
Max cruise speed
321 kt · 369 mph 594 km/h 321 kt 369 mph 594 km/h +2%
Max speed
321 kt · 369 mph 594 km/h 321 kt 369 mph 594 km/h +2%
Cruise speed
— — —
Approach speed
68 kt · 78 mph 126 km/h 68 kt 78 mph 126 km/h -18%
Rate of climb
2,600 ft/min 13 m/s 2,600 ft/min 13 m/s +24%
Range
956 nm · 1,100 mi 1,770 km 956 nm 1,100 mi 1,770 km +54%
Service ceiling
36,500 ft 11,100 m 36,500 ft 11,100 m +26%
Takeoff distance
1,000 ft 310 m 1,000 ft 310 m
Landing distance
790 ft 240 m 790 ft 240 m

Table of Contents

P-40 vs Spitfire at a glance

The Spitfire is the stronger pure fighter, and the gap grows with altitude. The P-40 Warhawk was the better fit for low-level fighting, and it was available in huge numbers.

P-40 WarhawkSpitfire
First flightOctober 14, 1938 (XP-40)March 5, 1936 (prototype K5054)
Service entry1939August 4, 1938 (Mk I, No. 19 Squadron)
Number built13,73820,351
ArmamentSix .50 caliber guns (P-40E)Eight .303 inch guns (original spec), later 20 mm cannon
SuperchargerSingle-stage, single-speedTwo-stage from the Mk IX (June 1942)
Airworthy today28About 60 (as of 2025)
Sources: Wikipedia articles on the P-40 and the Spitfire. Dimensions, weights and performance are in the spec comparison above.

Altitude: where the Spitfire pulled away

The P-40 used an Allison V-1710 with a single-stage, single-speed supercharger. That made it a poor high-altitude fighter, and it was best at 15,000 feet or lower over northwest Europe. The Flying Tigers’ planes had an effective ceiling of about 25,000 feet.

The Spitfire Mk IX went the other way. It used the two-stage Merlin 61, and an RAF test report said it “will climb easily to 38,000 feet.” The LF Mk IX reached 404 mph (650 km/h) at 21,000 feet.

That is the single biggest difference between them.

Guns: six .50s against eight .303s

The P-40E carried six .50 caliber machine guns, three in each wing. Early P-40N blocks dropped one gun from each wing, leaving four, and later blocks put it back after field complaints.

The original Spitfire specification called for eight .303 inch Brownings, though early aircraft flew with only four because of a Browning shortage. Cannon came later: the B wing carried four .303s and two 20 mm Hispanos, and the C wing could carry four 20 mm cannon.

The heavier .50s hit harder than rifle-caliber .303s. Cannon-armed Spitfires closed that gap.

What the P-40 did well

The P-40 was among the fastest diving fighters of the early war. Fighting at low and medium altitude, it built a real record. Clive Caldwell of the RAAF scored 22 of his 28½ kills in P-40s, and more than 200 Allied pilots became aces in the type, at least 20 of them double aces.

The Flying Tigers (American Volunteer Group) claimed 297 enemy aircraft in about 6.5 months, for four of their own pilots lost in air-to-air combat, according to the group’s own records. Those are the group’s own claims.

On April 18, 1943, the 57th Fighter Group was credited with 74 aircraft destroyed in the “Palm Sunday Massacre” over the Mediterranean. Australia took 553 P-40Ns for the Royal Australian Air Force.

Its weak point was altitude and climb, which the sources describe as “fair to poor, depending on the subtype.” Later 1,200 hp Allisons and 1,400 hp Packard-built Merlins helped. See the full P-40 Warhawk page page for its specs.

What the Spitfire did well

The Spitfire’s elliptical wing gave the lowest induced drag for an untwisted wing. Aerodynamicist Beverley Shenstone described it as “the thinnest possible wing with room inside” for the undercarriage, guns and ammunition.

In the Battle of Britain, Spitfire units had a lower attrition rate and a higher victory-to-loss ratio than the more numerous Hurricane. Spitfires mainly engaged the Messerschmitt Bf 109E escort fighters, while Hurricanes went after bombers.

The design kept improving. The Mk V, the most numerous mark at 6,487 built, was a Mk I with the Merlin 45 series engine. When the Fw 190 outclassed the Mk Vb in 1942, the Mk IX arrived in June of that year.

Rolls-Royce Griffon engines later produced up to 2,340 hp. A post-war Spitfire F.24 reached 454 mph (731 km/h), though the F.24 came too late for the war.

For more on the type, see the Supermarine Spitfire page.

Which versions are being compared?

Neither name is one aircraft. The P-40 went from the B and C Tomahawk to the D Kittyhawk I, the six-gun E, and the N, built until November 1944. Early Allisons made 1,040 hp at sea level and at 14,000 feet.

Some stripped-down P-40N “hot rods” reached up to 380 mph, the highest top speed of any production P-40. That still sits below the Mk IX Spitfire, which topped 400 mph.

The Spitfire spans even more: the Mk I of 1938, the Mk V that began equipping units in early 1941, the Mk IX of June 1942, and Griffon marks beyond. A fair matchup is the P-40E against the Spitfire Vb, or the late P-40s against the Mk IX.

One more data point: the Royal Air Force received 330 P-40F and P-40L Kittyhawk Mk IIs under Lend-Lease. Soviet commanders judged the Kittyhawk clearly better than the Hurricane but “not in the same league as the Yak-1.”

How they were used

Both fought for the Allies, but in different places. The P-40 first fought with Desert Air Force squadrons in June 1941, then with the Flying Tigers in China and with American squadrons in the Dutch East Indies and the Mediterranean.

The Spitfire fought the Battle of Britain, and it stayed in production until February 1948. The P-40 line ended in November 1944.

P-40 vs Spitfire: who wins?

The Spitfire wins as a fighter. It climbed higher, kept power at altitude, and kept being upgraded until the war ended.

The P-40 wins on one narrow count: it was a hard-hitting low-level fighter with strong dive speed. Used in the right place, it did the job it was given.

If you want the P-40 against a different rival, try the P-40 Warhawk vs P-51 Mustang comparison. Or see where it lands in the American fighter planes of WWII.

FAQ

Yes, by the record. In the Battle of Britain, Spitfire units had a lower attrition rate and a higher victory-to-loss ratio than Hurricane units, and the design kept improving. The Mk IX answered the Fw 190 in June 1942, and Griffon-powered versions later reached up to 2,340 hp.
Of the 13,738 P-40s built, 28 are airworthy at the latest count, and three of those have been converted to two-seat, dual-control layouts. About 36 more airframes are under restoration. Only one airworthy P-40B exists in the world, G-CDWH at Duxford.
About 60 Spitfires were airworthy as of 2025, out of 20,351 built. Five of them belong to the Battle of Britain Memorial Flight.
No, not as a fighter at altitude. The Spitfire climbed higher and its two-stage Merlin kept power in thin air, while the P-40’s single-stage supercharger made it best at 15,000 feet or lower over northwest Europe. The P-40 earned its record at lower altitudes in the desert, China and the Pacific.
The P-40E carried six .50 caliber machine guns. The original Spitfire specification called for eight .303 inch Brownings, and later Spitfire wings added 20 mm cannon, such as the B wing with four .303s and two 20 mm Hispanos.

About the Author

Tim de Vries

Tim is the owner and lead editor of AeroCorner since 2019, overseeing aviation content covering aircraft, airlines, airports, and the broader aviation industry. Through years of researching, writing, editing, and publishing aviation-focused content, he has developed extensive practical knowledge of commercial aviation and air travel. Based in Asia and a frequent traveler himself, Tim also brings firsthand passenger experience to AeroCorner’s coverage. Outside of publishing, he has also explored aviation firsthand through hands-on flight training in New Zealand.