Table of Contents
In the US, a floatplane is not the opposite of a seaplane: it is one of the two kinds of seaplane. “Seaplane” is the umbrella word for any airplane that takes off from and lands on water.
The real comparison is floatplane vs flying boat. A floatplane sits on floats, and its fuselage stays out of the water. A flying boat floats on its own fuselage, which is shaped like a boat hull.
That one design choice decides most of what follows: how big the airplane can get, how rough the water can be, and whether it can pull up to a dock.
| Floatplane | Flying boat | |
|---|---|---|
| What keeps it afloat | Floats mounted under the fuselage, usually two | The fuselage itself, built as a hull, plus wingtip floats or sponsons |
| Fuselage in the water? | No, only the floats touch the water | Yes, the hull sits in the water |
| Usual origin | A land airplane converted to floats | Designed for water from the start |
| Size | Generally small | Generally far larger, carries far more |
| Waves | Twin floats are often limited to waves of about 1 foot (0.3 m) | Still grounded by heavy seas, one reason the type faded |
| Docking | Most can pull alongside a dock | A typical single-engine flying boat cannot bring its hull alongside |
| Examples | DHC-2 Beaver, DHC-3 Otter, Cessna Caravan on floats | PBY Catalina, Grumman Albatross, Hughes H-4 Spruce Goose |
The Spruce Goose was never a floatplane
Howard Hughes’ H-4 Hercules is often listed as a floatplane. It is a flying boat: its wooden hull sat in the water, and it remains the largest seaplane ever built.
What Is a Seaplane?
A seaplane is a powered fixed-wing aircraft that can take off from and land on water. Purists say it “alights” on water, but most pilots just say it lands.
Seaplanes come in two types: floatplanes and flying boats. That is the American usage, and it is the one this article follows.
British usage is different, which is where much of the confusion starts. In the UK, “seaplane” usually means a floatplane specifically, and a flying boat is called a flying boat.

US pilot licensing does not split the two either. Under 14 CFR 61.5, the FAA’s airplane class ratings are single-engine land, multiengine land, single-engine sea and multiengine sea.
There is no separate floatplane rating and no flying boat rating. A sea rating covers any airplane that operates from water.
What Is a Floatplane?
A floatplane has slender floats mounted under its fuselage. Only the floats normally touch the water, and the fuselage rides above it.
Floatplanes are often derived from land airplanes, with floats fitted in place of the wheeled landing gear. That is the type’s big advantage: nobody has to design a watertight fuselage, and the floatplane shares its development costs with a much larger run of land aircraft.
The de Havilland Canada Beaver, the Otter, the Twin Otter and the Cessna Caravan on amphibious floats are the classic examples. Floats are often interchangeable with wheels, which is why they turn up so often among bush planes.
Single float or twin floats
Floatplanes come in two layouts. A single-float design has one large float under the fuselage and small stabilizing floats under the wingtips, as on the Japanese Nakajima A6M2-N of World War II.
A twin-float design has two main floats side by side, much like the main wheels they replace. Two floats are the common layout.
The single float handles rough water better, because the long central float is attached to the strongest part of the airframe. Twin floats are easier to moor and board from, but they restrict handling, often to waves as small as 1 foot (0.3 m).

What Is a Flying Boat?
A flying boat is a seaplane whose fuselage is a hull, purpose-built to float. It lands on its belly, the way a boat sits in the water.
A hull on its own is not stable from side to side, so flying boats add stability with floats under the wings or with sponsons, stubby wing-like projections from the sides of the hull. The PBY Catalina retracted its wingtip floats in flight.
Flying boats were some of the largest aircraft of the first half of the 20th century. In the interwar years they were the basis of the international airlines, because they needed water instead of expensive runways.
The biggest of all was the Hughes H-4 Hercules, the “Spruce Goose,” built mostly of birch because aluminum was a wartime strategic material. It flew once, on November 2, 1947, and is now preserved in McMinnville, Oregon.

Big flying boats did not die with the Spruce Goose. Japan’s ShinMaywa US-2, an amphibian of about 100,000 pounds (45,000 kg), flies air-sea rescue for the Japan Maritime Self-Defense Force.
Floatplane vs Flying Boat: The Differences That Matter
Both types land on water, float for as long as they need to, taxi and take off again. Where they part ways is in what they can carry and where they can go.

Payload and size: the flying boat wins
Flying boats are generally far larger than floatplanes and can carry far more. The floats on a floatplane add empty weight, so the same airplane on floats carries less than it does on wheels.
Speed and climb: neither type escapes the drag
Floats hang in the airstream for the whole flight. They add drag as well as weight, so a floatplane climbs more slowly and cruises more slowly than its wheeled twin.
A flying boat has no floats under the fuselage, but it still carries wingtip floats or sponsons. That is why the Catalina made its tip floats retractable, at the cost of extra weight.
Docking and loading: the floatplane wins
A floatplane’s fuselage sits high on its floats, so on all but the largest seaplanes its wings clear docks and other obstacles. Most floatplanes can come alongside a dock to load.
A typical single-engine flying boat cannot bring its hull alongside a dock. Its passengers and cargo have to come aboard another way, or the airplane has to come ashore.
Rough water: it depends on the floats
Floatplanes typically cannot handle waves higher than about 12 inches (0.3 m). The single-float layout copes with rough water better than twin floats do.
Flying boats were never immune to the sea either. Heavy seas could stop their takeoffs and landings while land airplanes kept flying, which helped push the type out of mainstream service after World War II.
Cost to build: the floatplane wins
A floatplane needs no watertight fuselage, no hull strong enough to take the impact of a water landing and no planing shape to break free of the surface. A flying boat needs all three, built into an airframe that only ever serves the small market for water aircraft.
Where Amphibians Fit
An amphibious aircraft can use both runways and water. It is not a third type: there are amphibious floatplanes and amphibious flying boats, each with retractable wheels.
On an amphibious floatplane, the wheels retract into the floats, as on the amphibious Otter. On an amphibious flying boat such as the Grumman Albatross, they retract into the airframe.

The wheels cost weight, complexity, range and fuel economy. They also add a hazard that a pure seaplane never has.
Landing on water with the wheels down will almost always flip the airplane onto its back. So the amphibian pilot’s checklist has one more item that matters a great deal: wheels up for water, wheels down for land.
How Seaplanes Began: Floats Came First
The first working attempts at flying off water used floats, not hulls. In 1876, Frenchman Alphonse Pénaud patented a flying machine with a boat hull and retractable landing gear, but never built it.
Austrian Wilhelm Kress built his Drachenflieger on two aluminum pontoons in 1901. Its car engine was far too heavy for its power, and the machine was wrecked during water trials that October without managing a real flight.
On March 28, 1910, Henri Fabre flew his Hydravion off the water in France. It was a floatplane on three floats, the first aircraft to take off from water under its own power.

American Glenn Curtiss combined floats with wheels and made the first amphibian flights in February 1911. François Denhaut flew the first seaplane whose fuselage formed a hull on April 13, 1912, and by 1913 Curtiss was building what he called “flying-boats.”
Seaplanes then carried the interwar airlines and flew patrol and rescue through the airplanes of World War II. Wartime airport building, and landplanes that were less at the mercy of the weather, ended their mainstream role after 1945.
Are Seaplanes Still Used Today?
Yes, in a few niches: air transport around island chains, access to roadless lake country and firefighting.
Harbour Air in British Columbia, which calls itself the world’s largest all-seaplane airline, flies Beavers, Otters and Twin Otters on floats between Vancouver, Victoria, Nanaimo and the Gulf Islands. Vancouver and Victoria are coastal harbors, not lakes.

Flying boats survive where the hull earns its keep. The Canadair CL-415 Super Scooper, later built as the Bombardier 415, is an amphibious flying boat designed specifically for aerial firefighting.

At the small end, the Icon A5 is an amphibious light-sport flying boat aimed at recreational flyers, with customer deliveries from 2016.
Seaplane vs Floatplane: Which Is Better?
Since a floatplane is a seaplane, the useful question is which kind of seaplane fits the job.
Choose a floatplane for small loads, docks and short hops, and for the option of swapping back to wheels. It is the cheaper, more common and more practical choice for nearly every private pilot and air taxi.
Choose a flying boat when size and payload come first, as with water bombers and maritime rescue. That is why the big seaplanes still flying today are almost all hulls.
FAQ
Sources and references used for research and fact-checking.
- Wikipedia, Seaplane (floatplane and flying boat types, design, history)
- Cornell Law School LII, 14 CFR 61.5: Certificates and ratings issued under this part
- Wikipedia, Amphibious aircraft
- Wikipedia, Hughes H-4 Hercules
- Wikipedia, Fabre Hydravion
- Wikipedia, Kress Drachenflieger
- Wikipedia, Harbour Air
- Wikipedia, Canadair CL-415
- Wikipedia, ShinMaywa US-2
- Wikipedia, Icon A5
Get the Newsletter
The latest aviation news and stories sent to your inbox.
About the Author
Salomon has been interested in aviation ever since his parents took him on a Boeing 720 to see his relatives. When he’s not writing his latest aviation article, he can be found planespotting, reading up on on aviation news or in the cockpit of his favorite aircraft!